10 Best Gel Eyeliners in 2019

best overall rating
  • Smudge-free eyeliner
  • Lasts up to 12 hours
  • Easy-grip tip
premium choice rating
  • Gel crayon
  • Long-lasting color
  • Lengthen the crayon through twisting the bottom
great value rating
  • Two different pots of gel eyeliner: one black and one brown
  • Two different applicator brushes included
  • Waterproof formula

Eyeliner is a staple of most make-up kits, helping you to define your lashes and widen your eyes.  Traditionally, an eyeliner came in a pencil which enabled the user to draw along their top and bottom lash line.  This type of eyeliner does not provide exact precision or definition and in fact may cause a great deal of smudging, particularly under the eye area.  To create a more precise eyeliner look, a gel eyeliner could be the answer, creating a buildable look which is renowned for being long-lasting and hard-wearing.

Gel eyeliner is different from liquid eyeliner, however, as liquid eyeliner is a faster solution which may provide a degree of discomfort when dried.  Gel eyeliner can combat this due to the softer formula utilized, additionally enabling you to create a more professional, built-up look.

A wide range of both gel and liquid eyeliners are currently saturating the market, in addition to a range of different formats such as the gel crayon, each providing the user with its unique benefits. Below is our list of ten of the best gel eyeliners currently available for you to purchase, helping you to decide which gel eyeliner is perfect for you and your look.

View the 10 Best Gel Eyeliners

best overall rating

1. Maybelline New York Eyestudio Liquid Eyeliner

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Maybelline New York Eyestudio Liquid Eyeliner provides a smudge-free eyeliner which promises to last up to 12 hours.  An easy-grip hold is provided in addition to a precise tip, helping you to create the exact look you desire.  Offering a waterproof formula, your eyeliner may be removed with either make-up remover or micellar water, gently cleansing and preparing your skin.

Maybelline New York Eyestudio Liquid Eyeliner is available in black, brown, green, and blue shades and comes complete with a 0.4 mm tip to ensure a precise application.  The formula is safe for sensitive eyes as well as being safe for users of contact lenses.

Maybelline New York Eyestudio Liquid Eyeliner is a great eyeliner to use for sensitive eyes and individuals who wear contact lenses.

Why We Like It
  • Smudge-free eyeliner
  • Lasts up to 12 hours
  • Easy-grip tip
  • Waterproof formula
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Type
Liquid Eyeliner
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
12 Hours
premium choice rating

2. Marc Jacobs Beauty Gel Crayon

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Marc Jacobs Beauty Gel Crayon comes in a 0.1 oz crayon pencil in a striking black shade.  This waterproof gel eyeliner provides a super-malleable formula which glides onto the skin effortlessly, creating a precise look and a flawless finish every time.  Offering a long-lasting, all-day formula, this gel eyeliner comes complete with a built-in sharpener to ensure that your gel crayon is precise with a sharp point. Additionally, the gel eyeliner crayon lengthens through merely by twisting the base of the product.

Marc Jacobs Beauty Gel Crayon offers the user a gel crayon which can be sharpened to create a precise, sharp tip.

Why We Like It
  • Gel crayon
  • Long-lasting color
  • Lengthen the crayon through twisting the bottom
  • Built-in sharpener to ensure a precise tip
  • Striking black shade
Type
Gel Crayon
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day
great value rating

3. UCANBE 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

UCANBE 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set comes complete with two pots of gel eyeliner, one pot in a soft brown shade and one pot in a striking black shade.  Additionally, two different applicator brushes are included, a standard eyeliner brush and an angled eyeliner brush.  The gel formula is waterproof as well as long-lasting, providing a smudge-free finish which lasts all day and can only be removed with a good make-up remover solution.

UCANBE 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set is versatile and adaptable, enabling you to tailor the product according to your needs.  For example, you could apply the black gel formula as an eyeliner and then apply the brown gel formula to your eyebrows, creating a stylish and precise finish.

UCANBE 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set contains everything you need to create a sophisticated and flawless look.

Why We Like It
  • Two different pots of gel eyeliner: one black and one brown
  • Two different applicator brushes included
  • Waterproof formula
  • Smudge-free finish
  • Remove make-up with make-up remover
Type
Two gel Pots With two Brushes
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day

4. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Duo

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Duo provides two pots of gel-based eyeliner along with a professional eyeliner applicator brush.  Included within the set is one pot of striking black gel eyeliner which will create an intense finish across the eyes, along with a pot of brown gel eyeliner which can also be used as an eyeliner or can be used to define the eyebrows.  Both pots of gel are separately provided in 0.1 oz containers and are applied with an ultra-fine brush to ensure a precise and flawless application is achieved.

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner Duo offers a complete set for your eye make-up kit, helping you to create an intense and stylish look.

Why We Like It
  • Two pots of gel-based eyeliner
  • One-pot of black gel eyeliner and one pot of brown gel eyeliner
  • An ultra-fine brush is included
  • Intense finish
  • Long-lasting application
Type
Two gel Pots With two Brushes
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
Several Hours

5. L’Oréal Paris Super Slim Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

L'Oréal Paris Super Slim Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner is a super-slim eyeliner which provides long-lasting results.  The easy to hold pen ensures a complete grip, helping you to create a precise application with the 0.4 mm tip.  Providing a smudge-free eyeliner, you can create sleek lines and dramatic looks which exude a professional finish.

L'Oréal Paris Super Slim Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner is the perfect eyeliner for individuals who want to create quick and effortless results.

Why We Like It
  • Super-slim eyeliner
  • Long-lasting results
  • Easy-grip
  • 0.4 mm tip
  • Professional finish
Type
Liquid Eyeliner Pen
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
12 Hours

6. AMC EYELINER Liquid GEL

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

AMC EYELINER Liquid GEL  is a professional gel pot which enables a smudge-free application.  The striking black color contains high-intensity pigments to ensure a rich color is achieved, utilizing the creamy formula to provide a crease-proof finish.  The formula provides a matte, waterproof finish which stays put all day.  Additionally, the gel formula is hypoallergenic and is not tested on animals, being vegan-friendly.

AMC EYELINER Liquid GEL is vegan-friendly and is not tested on animals, providing a good alternative for many individuals without compromising on style.

Why We Like It
  • Professional gel pot
  • Smudge-free application
  • A creamy, matte formula
  • Waterproof finish
  • Last all-day
Type
Gel Pot
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day

7. Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Pen

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Pen is a smudge-free liquid eyeliner which is long-lasting, lasting up to 12 hours after the initial application.  The brush of the pen offers smooth and even lines in addition to a continuous flow, providing a waterproof formula which can be adapted to suit different tastes and styles.  The formula is suitable for sensitive eyes in addition to individuals who wear contact lenses, making this the perfect choice for many users.

Docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Pen is an excellent choice for individuals who want to apply their eyeliner while creating a dramatic look quickly.

Why We Like It
  • Liquid eyeliner
  • Lasts up to 12 hours
  • Continuous flow brush
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
Type
Liquid Eyeliner Pen
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
12 Hours

8. MAC Fluidline Eye Liner Gel Blacktrack

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

MAC Fluidline Eye Liner Gel Blacktrack is a pot of gel eyeliner which is capable of creating an effortless, professional look.  Offering long-lasting wear and smudge-proof formula, this gel eyeliner provides a precise application with a soft, silky formula.  Furthermore, the MAC brand is synonymous with make-up professionals so you can be sure that you are receiving a high-quality product.

MAC Fluidline Eye Liner Gel Blacktrack provides a pot of gel eyeliner from a well-renowned, high-quality brand.

Why We Like It
  • Gel eyeliner pot
  • Professional brand
  • Long-lasting wear
  • Smudge-proof application
  • Smooth and silky formula
Type
Gel Pot
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day

9. e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner offers a pot of gel eyeliner which can create dramatic and professional finishes.  Precise lines are achieved through the creamy formula, providing intense, high-pigmented color.  Additionally, this gel eyeliner is easy to apply with an eyeliner brush and stays put all day long, creating waterproof and smudge-proof wear.  The e.l.f. brand is PETA certified as being suitable for vegans and also as being free of any cruelty to animals.

e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner provides a professional product which is free from any cruelty to animals and is suitable for vegans and is PETA certified.

Why We Like It
  • Gel eyeliner pot
  • Creates a dramatic look
  • Professional finish
  • Long-lasting and waterproof
  • PETA certified
Type
Gel Pot
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day

10. stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner offers a precise liquid eyeliner pen, containing a formula which is waterproof and smudge-proof, enabling you to apply your eyeliner effortlessly and with great ease.  The formula lasts all day and into the night, creating an even and crease-proof look.

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner provides an effortless liquid eyeliner which lasts all day and ensures a precise and direct application.

Why We Like It
  • Liquid eyeliner
  • Precise application
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof
  • Long-lasting
Type
Liquid Eyeliner Pen
Smudge-Proof
Yes
Time
All-day

Gel Eyeliner Buying Guide

It might seem like a simple beauty item but there is a lot to consider when it comes to choosing a gel eyeliner. There are various types such as liquid gel eyeliners, pencil eyeliners, gel eyeliners as well as eyeshadow eyeliners. The kind of eyeliner that you choose will define your look as well as the ease of the application process. Do you, for example, prefer a bold and intense look or gentler look?

If you are grappling with finding the best gel eyeliners for your needs, we are here to make the process as easy as possible for you while helping you find your perfect gel eyeliner accessory. Here is a breakdown on the main types of gel eyeliners:-

Liquid Eyeliners

If you love that feline winged liner look, then you should go for the liquid eyeliners. They can be packaged in a tube along with a thin brush for application but sometimes, the tube comes with a fine-tipped marker to be used in application. Liquid eyeliners will be ideal for you if you are after that slick flick with precise lines. They give a very bold look.

The drawback with these kinds of gel eyeliners is the difficulty with application as the tip is not easily controllable. Applying these requires a steadier hand as well as some patience. They are, certainly, not recommended for beginners. If you are just starting out with the gel eyeliners, give the pencil eyeliners a go. Slowly, you can move towards liquid eyeliners as you master the art and start creating that killer feline look!

Pencil Eyeliners

The pencil eyeliner will give you a smoky eye look and is perfect for you if you are just plunging yourself into the eyeliner game. Unlike the liquid eyeliners, they don’t require very precise strokes are, thus, relatively easier to apply since they are easier to control. The mode of operation is same as that of any other eye pencil but they are gentler and safer to use on your eyes. The pencil eyeliners need to be sharpened in order to get a good result.

However, no amount of sharpening will give you the level of precision that you will typically get with the liquid eyeliners. That is why these are generally preferred for beginners who will slowly graduate to the high precision gel eyeliners or for those who are just after that smoky eye look. The advantage, however, is the ease with which you can apply it.  The eye pencils are available in a broad array of colours. When you are purchasing these, make sure that you are picking one that has been ophthalmologist tested and which is proven to be safe.

Gel Eyeliners

This is perfect eyeliner for the smoky eye look. The gel eyeliner is packaged in a pot and can be applied to the eyes with a fine-tipped brush for a clean line. It is a thick creamy formula that you can manipulate with relative ease in order to obtain a desired look. It is fairly easy to smudge, thanks to the creaminess and it doesn’t create discomfort on your eyelids. The drawback with this is it does not dry faster enough and can also move a bit. Before applying, ensure that your eyes are well primed and try not to blink for some seconds after you have applied.

Eyeshadow Eyeliners

When it comes to the eyeliner application, you could choose to go with an intensely bold look or something softer and gentler. If you are looking for the latter, then the eyeshadow eyeliner is for you. The main advantage with eyeshadow is that it is quite faster while still giving you a super-polished look.

Application can be done via a small pencil brush or angled brush which can be used in drawing a smudge on the lash line or in choosing a preferred eyeshadow. It is not as long lasting as the liquid or gel eyeliners but good for daytime. You also have a vast array of colors that you can pick from!

Is the Gel Eyeliner Smudge Proof?

Whether you prefer a bold smoky look or something gentler or subtler, a smudge or smear could ruin everything! Neither do many women like applying a dried out pencil on their eyes. Many women will, thus go far the liquid or gel eyeliners and you need to make sure it will have good staying power and keep the clean lines, especially for the crispy feline look.

Does the Product come with a Brush?

An application brush is an integral part of any gel eyeliner. When purchasing one, determine whether the product has a brush that you can use to make those straight lines.

What Colors are Available?

Some of the gel eyeliners come with a color palette while others are only available in black. Based on your unique needs, ascertain this before making a purchase.

Gel eyeliners are a must-have in any self-respecting makeup lover’s makeup bag, and with so many different quality liners on the market, there is no excuse for boring eyes. Gel liners are preferred over standard liners for many reasons, one of which being the easy application, and they tend to go on very smoothly.

No more racoon eyes or looking like your 7-year old sister applied your eye makeup with her eyes closed. Whether you are after a long-lasting, waterproof or colored gel liner (or all of the above), there will be the perfect liner for you on this list of the best sellers.